Don't borrow from Peter to pay Paul, especially if you're planning to file for Bankruptcy!

Borrowing money leading up to a bankruptcy can cause multiple problems.

First, the debt for those funds could be non-dischargeable, meaning you will still owe it after the bankruptcy.  An example of how this could arise, was described in a previous post: Should I Pay My Student Loan with a Credit Card?  Debts such as student loans, certain judgments for personal injury resulting from gross negligence and or drunk driving and debts obtained by fraud cannot be discharged under the bankruptcy code.  If you borrow from another source, such as a credit card, to pay that loan then the new debt will be non-disagreeableness because the funds were obtained with the intention of filing bankruptcy and furthermore, the new loan can be treated the same as the original debt.

This means that even if the credit card company doesn't object to the discharge, they still might be able to pursue you after the discharge, just like a student loan company could (although best practice for the credit card company would be to object prior to the discharge).

Second, if you used these borrowed funds to pay another debt, those funds might be subject to taking by the bankruptcy court as a preference (a debt paid to the disadvantage of other creditors).  If that debt was a non-dischargeable debt, then you may still end up owing that debt after the bankruptcy, and the trustee could use those funds to pay other debts.

Third, and even worse, if the bankruptcy court found that you were attempting to commit a fraud upon the Court by moving this debt, the Court could deny your discharge altogether.

Finally, you could even be subject to criminal liability if the borrowing is determined to be a fraud, meaning you never intended to pay it back.  Fraud is a state crime and bankruptcy fraud is a federal crime.  

What is the difference between Chapter 7 and Chapter 13 bankruptcy?

Generally speaking, a Chapter 7 Bankruptcy involves a total liquidation of the debtor’s assets (although the debtor may keep certain allowable exempt assets), and any non-exempt assets are used to satisfy the debtor’s unpaid debts.  Any remaining dischargeable debts are discharged, meaning they are no longer owed.  A Chapter 7 case places no limits on the amount of debt that may be discharged; however, there are income qualifications in order to be eligible for Chapter 7 as a result of the 2005 changes to the Bankruptcy law.

A Chapter 13 case places no income restrictions on the debtor, so if you cannot file Chapter 7 because you do not pass the means test, you can likely file Chapter 13.  Chapter 13 begins much like a Chapter 7 case, but after the liquidation of non-exempt assets, if any, the debtor will pay a certain amount based on his available income and after deduction of living expenses to the U.S. Trustee, who will distribute payment to creditors on a pro-rata basis.  The debtor will make monthly payments for 3-5 years, depending on certain factors, and then, as long as the debtor makes payments every month, the remaining unpaid portion of most debts will be discharged (though some debts, such as student loans may still be owed even after completion of the plan).

Chapter 13 has the benefit of permitting the debtor to spread out the repayment of certain debts over a 3-5 year period that would be otherwise non-dischargeable, such as tax debt, or student loans.  Additionally, the debtor could use Chapter 13 to avoid foreclosure and pay back mortgage arrearages over the term of the plan, which is helpful in cases where the lender is demanding a high “cure” amount to voluntarily get a house out of foreclosure.

Bankruptcy & Litigation Series: #10 Criminal Cases

Over the course of our bankruptcy & litigation series we have explored many ways that a bankruptcy can affect the course or outcome of a civil case.  Criminal cases, however, are not typically affected by bankruptcy.

The Automatic Stay will not stay the imposition of a criminal sentence or criminal penalty.

Criminal penalties are non-dischargable to the extent such debt is for a fine, penalty, or forfeiture payable to and for the benefit of a governmental unit, and is not compensation for actual pecuniary loss.

Additionally, debts arising out of frivolous claims filed by prisoners are not dischargable.

Bankruptcy & Litigation Series: #2 My Ex is filing Bankruptcy!

While we have previously posted about the many issues that can arise when a bankruptcy happens at the same times as a divorce, what happens if a bankruptcy is filed after the divorce is final?

If a Bankruptcy action is filed immediately after the divorce becomes final it is possible for the Bankruptcy Court to undo the Agreement or Judgment of the Divorce Court if it appears the parties were attempting to defraud creditors (for instance if all of the assets were transferred to the non-debtor spouse rather than split equitably).  If the division is equitable, though, then it is unlikely that the Bankruptcy Court would want to revisit the divorce division.

However, the debtor might be bound to make payments in the divorce case which could affect eligibility for bankruptcy, and might have made promises to divide property that is now an issue. Domestic Relations Orders are non-dischargeable in most cases and therefore the decisions made in a divorce settlement, will have significant impact on what can and can't be discharged in the bankruptcy. There are three main areas where a bankruptcy can affect or be affected by a divorce judgment:  property division issues, support issues, and joint debts.

Property Division Issues in a Post-Divorce Bankruptcy:

If a divorce judgement requires that certain property be transferred from the debtor to their ex-spouse then the bankruptcy could affect that transfer.  If the transfer is made within 1 year prior to the bankruptcy then this could be considered a transfer to an insider and if it is not for fair value (for instance if the property division was not equitable), then the bankruptcy court can, upon motion of the trustee, require that the property be returned to the debtor's estate.

If the transfer hasn't been made yet, then that property is included in the debtor spouse's bankruptcy estate and the ex-spouse becomes another creditor of the estate.  Whether they take priority or not will depend on the nature of the property to be divided, and whether their claim is a non-dischargable domestic relations order or not.  Domestic relations orders are treated slightly differently for Chapter 7 and Chapter 13 bankruptcies, so the type of bankruptcy that is filed may also affect whether the property transfer is required or not.

Usually a failure to transfer property required by a Divorce Judgment would subject the debtor spouse to a Complaint for Contempt in the Probate & Family Court.  However, the Bankruptcy Court takes precedence and the Automatic Stay prevents creditors (even ex-spouses) from proceeding in other courts without first getting the permission of the Bankruptcy Court.

Support Issues in a Post-Divorce Bankruptcy:

Alimony and Child Support are considered Domestic Support Obligations, which are non-dischargable and must be paid by the debtor in a bankruptcy.  Any child support or alimony arrears are non-discharable in a bankruptcy and take priority over other debts.  In addition, if the family court awards the costs and attorneys fees of collecting alimony and child support in a Contempt action, those debts are non-dischargable as well.  In a Chapter 13, arrears may be paid overtime as part of the plan, but in a Chapter 7 they remain due immediately.

Practically speaking, going through a bankruptcy, might gain a debtor spouse some leeway from the Probate & Family Court in obtaining a payment plan for payback of the arrears, but they will still need to be paid.  If the ongoing support order itself is incorrect or onerous, this cannot be changed in the Bankruptcy Court, but can still be revisited by the Probate & Family Court by the filing of a Complaint for Modification.

If the debtor spouse is receiving child support or alimony this counts towards their income for bankruptcy means test purposes.  If it is owed but is not being paid then it does not need to be included, though the arrears may be an asset that should be listed.

Joint Debt Issues in a Post-Divorce Bankruptcy:

Post-Divorce there may be debts for which both parties are liable to the creditor but one or the other party has agreed (or been ordered) as part of the divorce to pay these debts.  Some typical examples of joint debts are home mortgages, joint credit cards, joint tax debt, and co-signed car loans.  If a joint debt is not paid off in the divorce, then from the creditor's perspective it is still owed by both parties.  If the divorce judgment requires one spouse to pay the debt and they do not make payment, it will affect both spouse's credit and the creditor can come after either or both of them to collect.  The spouse who was supposed to be protected in the divorce can likely file a Complaint for Contempt against the other spouse but this won't undo any credit damage and doesn't stop the collection action by the creditor.

In a Bankruptcy, the debtor is required to list co-debtors and the Bankruptcy Court can discharge debts to the third party creditor.  Whether or not the obligation of a debtor spouse to their ex-spouse is also discharged will depend on whether or not it is considered a domestic support obligation or non-dischargable domestic relations order.  It is likely important for the ex-spouse to participate in the bankruptcy and file a Proof of Claim if they believe there is an obligation to them as well as the creditor.  However, it is also important to note that even if a debt is non-dischargable, as a practical matter it may still be difficult to collect.  A debtor with no assets, found in Contempt in the Probate & Family Court, may not be able to pay the joint debt and the creditor will still pursue the non-bankrupt spouse.  It is therefore important to anticipate potential issues such as this at the time of the divorce, especially if it is obvious that one spouse's budget will not allow them to pay the bills they are agreeing to pay.

Bankruptcy and Student Loans: Another Infographic

The infographic below provides a summary of the student loan debt problem and the limitations of the current bankruptcy law to resolve that problem.  For a more in depth review of these issues see our previous post: Can bankruptcy help with my student loans?.



From: OnlineColleges.net

Reprinted from OnlineColleges.net.

Kelsey & Trask, P.C. provides this graphic for informational purposes only. We do not endorse nor claim endorsement from the source site or organization. Kelsey & Trask, P.C. is not responsible for any information contained therein, unless indicated specifically on that site.

What to do when you receive a Notice of Bankruptcy? Step 3: Identify Deadlines.

If you receive a Notice of Bankruptcy, it will contain certain deadlines and meeting dates.  The sample below shows where some of those deadlines will appear:

These dates are important because they limit what you can and cannot do in a case, and if you miss any of these deadlines you may have given up your rights to make certain objections or claims.  You should read the Notice carefully to make sure you understand all of the information contained therein.  To highlight some of these limits we have indicated them with red arrows in the sample Notice above.

Some of the important dates and limitations that appear on the Notice are as follows, in descending order as they appear on the Notice:

The date of filing:  This is the date that the debtors case was filed with the court and some of the other dates will depend on this date.

The meeting of creditors:  This is the date that the Section 341 Meeting of Creditors is first scheduled to take place.  The Creditor's Meeting is scheduled about 30 to 45 days after the bankruptcy petition is filed. At least seven days before this meeting, the debtor is required to provide to the trustee and any creditor requesting it a copy of their most recently filed tax returns and proof of income for the most recent 90-day period. The court-appointed Chapter 7 trustee will preside over this meeting. At the meeting, which the debtor is required to attend, the debtor will be asked to testify under oath as to the accuracy of the statements in the petition. Creditors have a right to attend this meeting and ask questions, though they are not required to.

Deadline to object to discharge or to challenge the dischargeability of certain debts:  
A creditor may object to the discharge of amounts owed to them by the debtor under certain circumstances. If a creditor objects to the discharge of any of the debts listed in the petition or schedules, such objection must be raised within 60 days after the first scheduled §341(a) Meeting of Creditors.  If you do not raise such an objection in a timely manner you risk waiving that right and having any such debt discharged.

Deadline to object to exemptions:  Certain property claimed by the debtor to be exempt (not reachable by creditors), may be claimed as exempt in error.  If that is the case, then that property might be used to pay creditors.  Once the §341(a) Meeting is concluded, creditors only have 30 days to object to these exemptions after which the trustee may (and likely will) release all of this exempted property back to the debtor.

Deadline for financial management course:  The debtor must take a financial management course within 60 days after the first scheduled §341(a) Meeting of Creditors, and if they don't they might not receive their discharge.

Automatic Stay: Immediately upon the filing date, an automatic stay prevents creditors from taking certain actions against the debtor.  If you violate the automatic stay you may be subject to sanctions and fines by the bankruptcy court.  You should ensure that you do not take any action against the debtor after the filing date without consulting with a bankruptcy attorney to ensure that you are not violating the automatic stay.

There may be other deadlines in cases that are different from the Chapter 7 no asset case in our example.  For example, in a case with assets there will also be a deadline for filing a Proof of Claim.    To ensure that you know all of the deadlines and meeting dates read your Notice carefully.

Once you understand what your deadlines are, the next step is to identify: What is your exposure to liability if the debtor receives their discharge?

Can bankruptcy help with my student loans?

Student loans have become a larger and larger portion of the average consumer's debt. As a country, our student loan debt is now higher than consumer spending debt. While consumer spending debt can typically be discharged in a bankruptcy, though, most student loan debt cannot.

As described in this infographic, student loan debt is exempt from many of the protections that consumers have available when it comes to other debts. If that seems unfair to you, then you're not alone. A few of our fellow legal bloggers have written some compelling posts on the necessity of changing the law on bankruptcy when it comes to student loans, and even the president has weighed in in favor of making a change.

However, until the law is changed, the current status is bleak for most. While a Chapter 13 plan can help you structure the payments and potentially stop wage garnishments, it will not reduce the overall debt, and at the end of the plan you may be back in the same position. In a Chapter 7, student loans are considered a non-dischargeable debt unless you can show "undue hardship." In the Brunner case, the U.S. Court of Appeals 2nd Circuit admits that that their is little help in the statute for defining what constitutes an "undue hardship."

The Court in that case required a three-part test to show undue hardship:

"(1) that the debtor cannot maintain, based on current income and expenses, a "minimal" standard of living for herself and her dependents if forced to repay the loans;

(2) that additional circumstances exist indicating that this state of affairs is likely to persist for a significant portion of the repayment period of the student loans; and

(3) that the debtor has made good faith efforts to repay the loans."

Essentially this means that to discharge the debt you have to show that you can't pay the loan now, you tried to pay the loan, and it is not likely you will be able to pay the loan before you die. Many believe this test limits the benefits of the "undue hardship" clause to the elderly or terminally ill.

For most, the best option may not be bankruptcy at all, at least not to deal with student loan debt. Until and unless the law changes, the Income Based Repayment Plan available through the Department of Education is the only option for reducing the burden of student loans when a partial financial hardship exists.

If you still think this is unfair, tell congress that you want it changed.

I am the primary borrower on a loan and my cosigner has filed for bankruptcy. What should I do to protect myself?

A co-signer is an individual who is promising to repay a loan in the event the primary borrower defaults. In many cases, having a co-signer on a loan may have been necessary to obtain the loan because the primary borrower’s credit rating was insufficient to qualify on their own, and the co-signer stepped in to assist the primary borrower to obtain financing.

As we discussed in our previous post, if the primary borrower defaults (or files bankruptcy), the co-signer will be required to pay the loan back. But what about the reverse situation?

How is the primary borrower affected if the cosigner files for bankruptcy?

Consider the same example: Adam wants to buy a car, but can only qualify for a loan with a co-signer. Betsy agrees to co-sign, but her name is not listed on the title as an owner of the vehicle. This time Betsy files for bankruptcy and obtains a discharge of the car loan. For the sake of simplicity, we will assume that Betsy has no ownership in the vehicle that may be attributed to her by the Trustee.

Adam is still legally obligated to repay the unpaid balance of the loan. However, when Adam pays off the loan, all liens will be released, and the title will be issued in Adam’s name. Most auto financing agreements make no distinction between the “borrower” and “co-borrower” aside from whose name the title will ultimately be issued to. As such, the bankruptcy of a co-borrower is similarly a breach of the terms of the loan, and could result in a default under the terms of the note. As before, the bankruptcy (and discharge) of the co-borrower’s obligation leaves the lender in a position where they can only pursue one individual, not two, in the event the loan is not paid.

This material departure from the original agreed upon terms could be considered a default, and in fact, many auto financing agreements specifically include such a term. However, it has been my experience that the lender will receive a greater financial return by accepting the primary borrower’s monthly payments than they would by repossessing the vehicle and selling it at auction, meaning that the primary borrower will likely keep the vehicle, despite the co-borrower’s bankruptcy.

In the event a co-borrower files for bankruptcy, the best thing that the primary borrower can do is seek to refinance the balance on the car loan, if possible. Many credit unions and some larger banks offer automobile refinancing loans. By refinancing the loan, the primary borrower has effectively paid off the loan securing the vehicle, and negated any circumstances which could trigger a default. If handled properly, and for a qualified borrower, it is often possible to keep payments the same, or even lower payments upon refinancing the car.

A borrower may be tempted to sign a reaffirmation agreement presented by the lender. However, executing the reaffirmation agreement is, in my opinion, not a legal guarantee that the bank will take no further action, nor will it cure any default under the terms of the note upon the co-borrower’s filing for bankruptcy. First, in order to cure the issue of default, at a minimum, the co-borrower filing for bankruptcy would have to sign. A reaffirmation agreement is an agreement arising in the context of a bankruptcy case. Here, the primary borrower is not seeking bankruptcy protection, nor is he electing to “remove” the debt from the discharge order; and therefore the primary borrower, Adam in our example above, has no standing to sign the reaffirmation agreement.

The bankruptcy of a co-borrower should not appear on Adam’s credit report, but because some lenders will automate their reports to credit agencies, there is a reasonable likelihood that the entry may make some indication of bankruptcy. If this happens, the information in the credit report is incorrect. It may be necessary to contact the three credit bureaus (Equifax, Experian, and Trans Union) as well as the lending institution to ensure that this information is correctly reported on the primary borrower’s credit report. Again, refinancing with a new loan is the simplest way to resolve this issue because then the loan will be listed as paid, and the new loan will report positively on a credit report (as long as you continue to pay it on time).

As with the decision to co-sign a loan, the decision to obtain a loan requiring a co-signer comes with significant legal consequences if the co-signer does not honor the terms of the note. Consider the need to take out a loan with a co-signer carefully, and if the co-signer files for bankruptcy , it may be worth your while to reach out to a bankruptcy attorney to better understand your options and obligations regarding the loan.

I co-signed a loan and the primary borrower has filed for bankruptcy. What should I do to protect myself?

A co-signer is an individual who is promising to repay a loan in the event the primary borrower defaults. In many cases, having a co-signer on a loan may have been necessary to obtain the loan because the primary borrower’s credit rating was insufficient to qualify on their own, and the co-signer stepped in to assist the primary borrower to obtain financing without considering the long-term ramifications of that decision.

If the primary borrower defaults (or files bankruptcy), the co-signer will be required to pay the loan back. Additionally, unless the co-signer is also a “co-purchaser”, the co-signer is burdened only with the responsibility of repaying the debt and receives none of the benefit of the loan.

Consider the following example: Adam wants to buy a car, but can only qualify for a loan with a co-signer. Betsy agrees to co-sign, but her name is not listed on the title as an owner of the vehicle. Adam files for bankruptcy, and surrenders (gives back the car to the lender) and obtains a discharge of the car loan. Betsy is still legally obligated to repay the unpaid balance of the loan, but does not get title to the car when she finally finishes paying off the car – which now belongs to the bank.

Being a co-signer can be extremely risky, and if the primary borrower files for bankruptcy, your credit can be affected. However, you can manage the credit damage by doing the following:

1. Determine whether the primary borrower intends to reaffirm the debt in bankruptcy court, (i.e., keep the car and continue paying the loan), or will surrender it back to the lender.

2. If the primary borrower is going to reaffirm the vehicle, ensure that they keep the payments current through bankruptcy, and sign the reaffirmation agreement.

3. If the primary borrower is not intending to reaffirm, or has already lost the vehicle due to repossession, the only way to protect your credit is to repay the loan pursuant to the terms of the agreement

4. Be aware that many loans include an acceleration clause, meaning that if one of the borrowers files bankruptcy, the entire balance of the loan is due. If the lender exercises their right to accelerate the loan, the co-signer may not be able to make regular monthly payments.

Remember, the decision to co-sign a loan is often made out of a desire to help a friend or family member, but it comes with significant legal consequences if they fail to repay. Consider any request to co-sign a loan carefully, and if the primary borrower files for bankruptcy , it may be worth your while to reach out to a bankruptcy attorney to better understand your options and obligations regarding the loan.

I’m being sued. Can a bankruptcy help?

If you are being sued on a debt collection matter, or other civil matter for which a money judgment can be imposed, filing bankruptcy may give you relief from your creditors. The Automatic Stay halts all existing court proceedings that the debtor is involved in, as well as any collection efforts for the individual's debts, until the bankruptcy proceedings are resolved.

In certain situations, the Automatic Stay might not prevent other court proceedings from continuing, at least in part. For example, in any family law case involving child support and custody, issues involving visitation or current child support are not subject to the Automatic Stay, but issues involving past due child support will be continued until the Automatic Stay is lifted at the end of bankruptcy proceedings.

The Automatic Stay is designed to provide some breathing room for the debtor in bankruptcy and provide the time and logistical ability to reorganize debts (as in a Chapter 11 or Chapter 13), or obtain a discharge (as in a Chapter 7 case). While the long-term resolution of a lawsuit will depend on the type of case, the Automatic Stay will provide some immediate protection for the debtor.

Ultimately, the debtor’s primary concern will be whether the debt or obligation on which the lawsuit is based will be discharged in bankruptcy. Absent fraud or certain other factors, most lawsuits arising out of consumer debts (e.g., lawsuits on unpaid credit cards or mortgage deficiencies following a foreclosure) are dischargeable under Chapter 7, and can be discharged following the successful completion of a Chapter 13 plan. However, the following debts arising under some suits cannot be discharged:

1. Lawsuits for unpaid taxes, custom duties, or debts to pay taxes or custom duties.
2. Lawsuits collecting student loan debt.
3. Lawsuits to collect unpaid spousal or child support.
4. Lawsuits filed by a spouse, former spouse, or child to enforce a Court Order obtained in a domestic relations proceeding.
5. Lawsuits where the debt was included in a previous bankruptcy wherein discharge of that particular debt was waived, such as reaffirmed debts.
6. Lawsuits for debts owed for money, property, services, or refinancing of credit, if obtained by false pretenses, or false representations, or actual fraud.
7. Lawsuits involving consumer debts for luxury goods obtained within ninety (90) days of the date of filing of the bankruptcy petition.
8. Lawsuits involving cash advances obtained within seventy (70) days of the date of the filing of the bankruptcy petition.
9. Lawsuits involving debts owed for fraud or defalcation while acting in a fiduciary capacity, or embezzlement or larceny.
10. Debts owed for fines, penalties, or forfeitures payable to and for the benefit of governmental entity.
11. Lawsuits and debts owed for death or personal injury arising from the operation of a motor vehicle, boat, or aircraft while intoxicated by drugs or alcohol.

It is important to understand that the filing of a case will temporarily stop the lawsuit for many of the above claims, even though the actual debt is nondischargable. However, once the protections of the Automatic Stay expire, or the opposing party obtains permission from the Bankruptcy Court to move ahead, the case may proceed, and you may be required to pay any debt arising out of the above types of lawsuits, even after bankruptcy.

5 Common Misconceptions about Bankruptcy: #3 Freedom from All Debts

Unlike other legal issues, unmanageable financial debt is a problem that many are too ashamed to discuss with their friends and family. This means that many people piece together their knowledge about bankruptcy from unreliable and confusing sources. The result is that there are a lot of misconceptions about bankruptcy.  In these 5 posts we will write about the most common misconceptions that we hear from clients in our office.

Common Misconception #3: Freedom from All Debts

Another common misconception about bankruptcy, is that once it is over you no long owe any money to anyone.  In some cases this is true, but those cases are very rare.

Most people have some debts which are nondischargeable, which means they will still owe those debts, even after the bankruptcy is complete.  You may still be responsible for most taxes and student loans; debts incurred to pay non-dischargeable taxes; domestic support and property settlement obligations; most fines, penalties, forfeitures and criminal restitution obligations; certain debts which are not properly listed in your bankruptcy papers; and debts for death or personal injury caused by operating a motor vehicle, vessel or aircraft while intoxicated on alcohol or drugs.

Also, if a creditor can prove that a debt arose from fraud, breach of fiduciary duty, or theft, or from a willful and malicious injury, the bankruptcy court may determine that the debt is not discharged.

5 Common Misconceptions about Bankruptcy: #5 Picking & Choosing

Unlike other legal issues, unmanageable financial debt is a problem that many are too ashamed to discuss with their friends and family. This means that many people piece together their knowledge about bankruptcy from unreliable and confusing sources. The result is that there are a lot of misconceptions about bankruptcy. In the next 5 posts we will write about the most common misconceptions that we hear from clients in our office.

 Common Misconception #5: Picking & Choosing

Many people believe that they get to pick which debts to "bankrupt." Some clients don't want to report a debt owed to a family member, because they don't want that person knowing about their bankruptcy. Other clients only want to "bankrupt" specific debts but not all of their debts. That is not how bankruptcy works. 

Every debt you owe must be completely and accurately disclosed in the documents filed to commence your bankruptcy case. Bankruptcy is not a "pick and choose" proceeding. You cannot not put some debts in and leave other debts out. Intentionally omitting debts from your bankruptcy case may result in the non-dischargability of those debts, the dismissal of your bankruptcy case, fines, or imprisonment for bankruptcy fraud.

FAQ #30: I Received My Discharge, but Creditors are Still Calling Me. What Should I Do?

Although you no longer owe any scheduled (and dischargeable) debts following your bankruptcy, it is important that you do not simply ignore a creditor’s efforts to collect a debt after discharge.

Call your attorney right away, and be sure to provide copies of any letters, bills or notices you received, or the name, business name and telephone number of the creditor or collection agency that has contacted you. Any creditor that received notice of your bankruptcy and was included on the creditor matrix cannot continue to collect any debt that was discharged. Any entity that does so is in contempt of an Order of the U.S. Bankruptcy Court.

Any efforts to attempt to collect a discharged debt are unlawful, and if the creditor’s actions are deemed to be a willful violation of the Court’s Order, the creditor can be forced to pay the debtor’s actual damages, and, in certain cases, punitive damages. As a practical matter, most cases of a creditor attempting to collect on a discharged debt can be resolved with a simple letter to the creditor, as well as a copy of the Discharge and Creditor Matrix. Additional bankruptcy litigation (and the costs associated with having to go to Court is usually not necessary.

FAQ #29: What happens if I forget to add a creditor to my bankruptcy?

As we discussed in response to a previous question (Do I have to include all my bills when I file bankruptcy?), every debt you owe must be completely and accurately disclosed in the documents filed to commence your bankruptcy case. Bankruptcy is not a "pick and choose" proceeding. You cannot not put some debts in and leave other debts out. Intentionally omitting debts from your bankruptcy case may result in the non-dischargability of those debts, the dismissal of your bankruptcy case, fines, or imprisonment for bankruptcy fraud.

The bankruptcy court requires that you undertake an appropriate level of “due diligence” to determine your debts and your potential creditors. This means that you need to make a concerted effort to review supporting documentation, such as a credit report, account statements, collection notices, and other information pertaining to the existence of a debt or potential claim. When you sign your bankruptcy petition, and testify at the §341(a) Meeting of Creditors, you are indicating to the Court that your petition is “true, accurate and complete”. Bankruptcy will only discharge “scheduled” debts – meaning the creditor must receive notice of the bankruptcy – and any debt not listed in your creditor matrix may not be discharged.

So, then, what happens if you unintentionally omit a creditor?

In most cases, if the mistake was unintentional (i.e., you forgot about the debt, or did not know about the claim), and you have not yet received your discharge, it is possible to file an amended schedule of your debts to include the missing items. This involves preparing a new list of debts, and preparing a Motion for Leave to Amend Schedules, which is a formal request to the Court for permission to add the new creditors. The Court will almost always allow the motion, but there is a $26.00 filing fee for the Motion to Amend. Additionally, the Court will usually give your added creditors sufficient time to object to claimed exemptions or the dischargability of the new debt. The added time will delay your discharge. Still, it’s better to wait a little extra than to owe the debt following the bankruptcy.

If you have received your discharge and your case has been closed, the process is more complex. You must first request that the Court re-open your bankruptcy case. Cases can be re-opened for any number of reasons, including “to administer assets, to accord relief to the debtor, or for other cause” (See 11 U.S.C. § 530(b)). Courts have nearly universally held that re-opening a case to include an unintentionally-omitted creditor will “accord relief to the debtor”, and will allow the request. The Court will charge a filing fee of $260.00 to re-open a closed bankruptcy case, so be sure to conduct your “due diligence” and get things right the first time.

FAQ #13: What debts will bankruptcy not erase?

Even if you receive a general discharge, some particular debts are not discharged under the law. You may still be responsible for most taxes and student loans; domestic support and divorce settlement obligations; most fines, penalties, forfeitures and criminal restitution obligations; debts which are not properly listed in your bankruptcy filing; and debts for death or personal injury caused by operating a motor vehicle, vessel or aircraft while intoxicated on alcohol or drugs. Debts incurred to pay non-dischargeable debts will themselves be non-dischargeable as well. In simpler terms this means that you cannot, for instance, use a credit card to pay your student loans and then discharge the credit card.

Also, if a creditor can prove that a debt arose from fraud, breach of fiduciary duty, or theft, or from a willful and malicious injury, the bankruptcy court may determine that the debt is not discharged.

My Ex Owes Support and is Filing for Bankruptcy: What Now?

We previously wrote an article regarding the dischargeability of domestic support obligations, such as child support and alimony. But just knowing that the arrears are not dischargeable may not be enough. How do you collect them without violating bankruptcy law?

If you are owed child support, alimony, separate support or money or property pursuant to a divorce separation agreement, and the other party files for bankruptcy, it is important that you first know your rights regarding the dischargability (or non-dischargability) of those obligations. Each of the above are handled differently depending on the type of obligation (support versus a property settlement) and the type of bankruptcy (Chapter 7 or Chapter 13).

CHAPTER 7 CASES

In Chapter 7 Cases, the answer is simple: domestic support obligations and divorce property settlements are non-dischargeable. According to the bankruptcy code at 11 U.S.C. § 523(a):

“[a] discharge [in a Chapter 7 Case] does not discharge an individual debtor from any debt… (5) for a domestic support obligation; [or] (15) to a spouse, former spouse, or child of the debtor and not of the kind described in paragraph (5) that is incurred by the debtor in the course of a divorce or separation or in connection with a separation agreement, divorce decree or other order of a court of record, or a determination made in accordance with State or territorial law by a governmental unit."

So, if a payor owes you back child support, alimony or or property division payments pursuant to a divorce agreement you should file an objection to the discharge of those debts, and then pursue your rights in the Probate and Family Court to obtain payment.

CHAPTER 13 CASES

Debtors may use the bankruptcy protections of Chapter 13 to pay back child support arrears according to the chapter 13 plan and avoid a potential contempt in Probate and Family Court. Therefore, most issues regarding unpaid child support or alimony (and payment of support arrears) arise in Chapter 13 Bankruptcy Cases. However, while bankruptcy can provide some protection to the debtor to pay back support over the course of the plan, the debtor must meet all requirements of the Massachusetts Local Bankruptcy Rules and the U.S. Bankruptcy Code in order to ensure they receive their discharge upon the completion of their plan.

A discharge in a Chapter 13 Case does not discharge an individual debtor from any debt for a domestic support obligation, but may discharge other debts, including debts arising out of a divorce or separation agreement that are not dischargeable in a Chapter 7 case. See 11 U.S.C. § 1328(a).

In order to receive a discharge of other debts (but not domestic support obligations) in a Chapter 13 case, the debtor must successfully complete the repayment plan, and must file a Motion for Discharge, and certify that all obligations for child support, spousal maintenance and alimony due that were due on or before the date of the motion, including all payments due under the plan for amounts due before the petition was filed and any domestic support obligations that arose after the filing of the petition have been paid. The debtor must serve a copy of the motion and certification on the beneficiary of the domestic support obligation.

At that point, the beneficiary may object to the entry of the debtor’s discharge if there are outstanding obligations and a discharge will not be granted unless all obligations have been paid. See 11 U.S.C. § 1328(a). See also Massachusetts Local Bankruptcy Rule 13-22 and Official Local Form 12.

However, there is one exception: domestic support obligations that are assigned to a governmental unit (i.e., collected by the Department of Revenue and distributed to the beneficiary) may be paid less than 100% through the plan, but only if disposable income is dedicated to the plan for a full five years. In this case, the debtor would continue to owe any child support not paid at the completion of the plan and DOR would continue to be involved at the end of the bankruptcy case.

Finally, bankruptcy will not change the current support obligations following bankruptcy. At the conclusion of either a chapter 7 or chapter 13 bankruptcy, the debtor’s obligations to pay child support remain unchanged, and must pay any obligations unless and until amended by an order of the Probate & Family Court. If you want to know more about amending support orders in the Probate & Family Court in Massachusetts view our information on Modifications.

What happens at the end of successful Individual Chapter 7 Bankruptcy?

When an individual files for Chapter 7 Bankruptcy, the debtor is essentially asking the bankruptcy trustee to manage the liquidation of any collectible assets and then requesting that the court discharge the remaining dischargeable debt.

The trustee will take any assets of value, which are not exempt, and distribute those assets to the creditors in order of priority. For more information about what types of assets are exempt visit our Exemptions page.

Any unsecured creditors that are left holding claims when the assets run out will be discharged unless they fall into a very limited list of non-dischargeable debts (such as student loans or most income tax debt).

If no objections are filed, then the debtor is issued a discharge, which is an order that prohibits discharged creditors from trying to collect their debts from the debtor. This is the typical end of a Chapter 7 Bankruptcy case, although there are certain objections or audits that can be filed later which could re-open or undo the discharge.

Avoid These 3 Traps Before Filing Bankruptcy

A significant majority of Chapter 7 Bankruptcy filings are completed without any significant problems to the Debtor or objection by Creditors, provided the Debtor (and their Counsel) properly and accurately discloses all necessary information required by the bankruptcy laws. However, the bankruptcy laws provide the grounds for creditors to object to the discharge of debts (meaning you will still owe the debt, even after filing bankruptcy)under certain circumstances.

A creditor may object to the discharge of amounts owed to them by the debtor under certain circumstances. If a creditor objects to the discharge of any of the debts listed in your petition or schedules, such objection must be raised within 60 days after the first scheduled §341(a) Meeting of Creditors. Alternatively, the trustee must move to dismiss your case within the 60-day period following the §341(a) Meeting of Creditors if he or she finds that the granting of relief would be an abuse of the provisions of Chapter 7.

So, what are traps to avoid objections to my petition?

Trap 1: New Debts Immediately Prior to Filing
If you incurred new debt of $500.00 or more for "luxury goods or services" within the 90-day period before your bankruptcy, or if you obtained a cash advance from a credit card or other loan in the amount of $750.00 or more within the 70-day period before your bankruptcy filing, that debt is presumed to be non-dischargeable, absent the debtor's showing to the contrary.

Trap 2: Debtor Dishonesty in Obtaining Debt
A creditor may object to your request to discharge a debt if the debt was obtained or incurred as a result of fraud, embezzlement or larceny, or any willful or malicious injuries you have caused others. If the Creditor establishes by a preponderance of the evidence that the debt was obtained by any of the above means, the debt will be deemed non-dischargeable.

Trap 3: Debtor Dishonesty in Filing for Bankruptcy
Creditors may object to the discharge of certain debts if you have concealed or destroyed any property or financial records; made any false statements in connection with incurring a debt or other financial obligation; withheld financial or other material information; failed to explain losses; failed to respond to material questions permitted under the Federal Rules of Bankruptcy Procedure; or if you were granted a discharge with respect to that debtor in a prior bankruptcy case filed within the last 6 years.

So, in conclusion, the best advice to consider if you are considering bankruptcy is to stop spending, or at least stop incurring new debt, and ensure you understand and completely disclose your financial history. As in the rest of life, honesty is the the best policy.

Under What Circumstances Can Creditors Object to the Discharge of a Debt?

A creditor may object to the discharge of amounts owed to them by the debtor under certain circumstances. If a creditor objects to the discharge of any of the debts listed in your petition or schedules, such objection must be raised within 60 days after the first scheduled §341(a) Meeting of Creditors. Alternatively, the trustee must move to dismiss your case within the 60-day period following the §341(a) Meeting of Creditors if he or she finds that the granting of relief would be an abuse of the provisions of Chapter 7.

If you incurred new debt of $500.00 or more for "luxury goods or services" within the 90-day period before your bankruptcy, or if you obtained a cash advance from a credit card or other loan in the amount of $750.00 or more within the 70-day period before your bankruptcy filing, that debt is presumed to be non-dischargeable, absent the debtor's showing to the contrary.

A creditor may object to your request to discharge a debt if the debt was obtained or incurred as a result of fraud, embezzlement or larceny, or any willful or malicious injuries you have caused others. If the Creditor establishes by a preponderance of the evidence that the debt was obtained by any of the above means, the debt will be deemed non-dischargeable.

Creditors may object to the discharge of certain debts if you have concealed or destroyed any property or financial records; made any false statements in connection with incurring a debt or other financial obligation; withheld financial or other material information; failed to explain losses; failed to respond to material questions permitted under the Federal Rules of Bankruptcy Procedure; or if you were granted a discharge with respect to that debtor in a prior bankruptcy case filed within the last 6 years.

Can I file Chapter 7 Bankruptcy Even if I Have Filed Before?

Whether or not you may re-file (and the amount of time that must pass before you may re-file bankruptcy) depends on whether or not you received a discharge under your most recent bankruptcy filing.

If you received a discharge under a Chapter 13 bankruptcy case, then you cannot file for relief under Chapter 7 unless:

1. Six years have passed since the discharge in the Chapter 13 case; or
2. You paid at least 70 percent of your allowed unsecured claims in the Chapter 13 case, and your plan was proposed in good faith and represented your best effort to pay.

If you received a discharged under a Chapter 7 bankruptcy case, then you cannot file for relief under Chapter 7 unless eight years have passed since the discharge in the previous Chapter 7 filing.

If you filed a Chapter 7 or Chapter 13 case that was dismissed because you failed to obey court orders or you voluntarily requested a dismissal and did not obtain a discharge, then you cannot file for relief under Chapter 7 unless 180 days have passed since the dismissal of the previous filing.