What to do when you receive a Notice of Bankruptcy? Step 4: What is your liability?

In our previous posts in this series you should have already identified why you received the Bankruptcy Notice and what the deadlines are that might apply to you.  In order to determine whether you should take any action related to this Notice, you now need to determine what you may have to lose.

If you are a creditor and you take no action, the debt owed to you may be discharged.  In most cases, there is nothing a creditor can do to prevent the discharge, especially in a no-asset case.  The right of the debtor to file for bankruptcy trumps your right to be paid by the debtor.  However, there are some examples where taking action can result in payment (or at least non-discharge of your debt).  Some examples where you may be able to prevent discharge of your debt, or all debts, is when the debtor committed fraud, when the debtor is trying to exempt property that should not be exempted, or when the debt is secured or otherwise protected from discharge (these are just some examples and is not intended to be an exhaustive list).

In any case where a creditor can prevent discharge, they are usually required to take some action to notify the court of their dispute and enforce their rights.  For example, in the case of fraud, the creditor must file an adversary proceeding challenging the discharge of that debt based on fraud.  In each individual case, you will have to determine if the value of preventing discharge of the debt is greater than the cost of enforcing that right.  In many such cases the creditor may reach settlement with the trustee regarding payment.

There are also situations where a bankruptcy may affect your liability, but there is nothing you can do about it.  For example, many codebtors will be affected by the bankruptcy of the debtor but have little rights to challenge the bankruptcy, because their liability is due to their own agreement with the creditor and they have no separately existing rights against the debtor.  This is often the case when one spouse, or ex-spouse files for bankruptcy.  Bankruptcy can have a major affect on debts owed by both spouses, and therefore property division, but if the divorce agreement doesn't appropriately address this possibility, the non-debtor spouse may have few or no options.  For more information about cosignors or the interplay of divorce and bankruptcy you may want to review these other posts:

I am the primary borrower on a loan and my cosigner has filed for bankruptcy. What should I do to protect myself?

I co-signed a loan and the primary borrower has filed for bankruptcy. What should I do to protect myself?

4 Facts Your Divorce Attorney Should know about Bankruptcy? Fact #4: Jurisdiction over Your Assets

4 Facts Your Divorce Attorney Should know about Bankruptcy? Fact #3: Jurisdiction over Your Debts

4 Facts Your Divorce Attorney Should know about Bankruptcy? Fact #2: Domestic Support Obligations

4 Facts Your Divorce Attorney Should know about Bankruptcy? Fact #1: The Automatic Stay

Once you've identified your exposure in a bankruptcy, the last step is to determine if you need help in limiting that exposure.  Should you hire a bankruptcy attorney to help you evaluate your claims? 

What to do when you receive a Notice of Bankruptcy? Step 2: Are you a creditor?

If you receive a Notice of Bankruptcy you need to determine why you received the Notice. You might be a creditor, an interested party, or a codebtor.  Creditors are not the only ones who receive a bankruptcy notice, and even if you're not a creditor you may have an interest in what happens in this bankruptcy case.

The Notice will not tell you why you received it.  A sample notice, shown below, doesn't have your name anywhere on it.  It does, however, have the name of the debtor and the case number.  These two pieces of information should help you determine whether you are a creditor or some other interested party.

The Debtor, whose name is listed on our sample notice above as Sample Debtor, is the person who has asked the bankruptcy court for relief with their debts.  If you are aware of a debt that the debtor owes you then you are a creditor and you should review the other information within that Notice.  As a creditor you have certain rights that may include filing a Proof of Claim and attending the Meeting of Creditors.

If you're not sure if the debtor owes you money, then you might be a creditor or you might be something else, such as a contingent creditor, a co-debtor, or simply an interested party.  To determine why you received this Notice, you must look at the schedules.  The Bankruptcy court documents are public record and may be reviewed at the court or online if you have a Pacer access account.  If you need help accessing these files any bankruptcy attorney will have an online account access and be able to look up the case file online.

Once you have access to the file, you will want to review the Bankruptcy Petition and Schedules to figure out where your name appears.  If you are a creditor then your debt should be listed in one of the Schedules of Creditors.

If you are not a creditor you may still have an interest in the bankruptcy proceedings for some other reason.  For example a codebtor (someone who is also responsible for a debt that the debtor owes) could be left being wholly responsible for a debt if the debtor is discharged of that debt.  You might be a codebtor if you cosigned for a loan for the debtor, or if they cosigned for a loan that you took out, or if you borrowed money together for any reason (such as co-owners of a house with a mortgage).  Codebtors are listed on the Schedule of Codebtors.

If you are not a codebtor or a creditor then your name may still appear somewhere else in the schedules, identifying why you received the Notice.  For example, you may receive a Notice of Bankruptcy if you have a lease or other contract with the debtor, even if they are not behind on their payments.  Reading all of the schedules carefully should help you discover why you received the notice, whether you are a creditor, codebtor or some other interested party.

Once you identify why you received the Notice, you can begin to evaluate what type of action you should take.  For example the Notice tells creditors what many of their rights and obligations may be.  The next step, therefore, is to identify: What are the important dates and deadlines I should keep in mind?

A Step-By-Step for Bankruptcy Creditors: What to do when you receive a Notice of Bankruptcy.

If you receive a Notice of Bankruptcy, like the sample shown below, you should ensure that you know why you received it and what your rights are.  The first step is to read the Notice.  It contains much of the information you need to know, as well as instructions on what to do if you wish to respond.

Receiving a Notice such as this one, likely means that you are a creditor and the debtor is trying not to pay the debt they owe you.  But you may have remedies if you take action and know your rights.

Over the next series of posts we will help you understand the steps you should take when you receive a Notice of Bankruptcy.  The questions you need answered include:

What kind of Bankruptcy is it (most likely options include 7, 11 and 13)?

Are you actually a creditor, or did you receive the Notice for some other reason?

What are the important dates and deadlines I should keep in mind?

What is your exposure to liability if the debtor receives their discharge?

Should you hire a bankruptcy attorney to help you evaluate your claims?

Once you answer these questions you will be prepared to respond to the Notice of Bankruptcy, appropriately.

I’m suing someone and they filed for bankruptcy. What happens next?

As we have discussed in previous posts, immediately upon filing a voluntary Petition for Bankruptcy, the protections of the Automatic Stay go into effect to protect the debtor in an active bankruptcy. 11 U.S.C. §362(a) provides that the commencement or continuation of any acts or proceedings against the debtor in an effort to collect or recover any debt is automatically stayed, and any further efforts at collection are prohibited and punishable by law. Pursuant to 11 U.S.C. §362(k), an individual injured by any willful violation of a stay provided by this section shall recover actual damages, including costs and attorneys’ fees, and, in appropriate circumstances, may recover punitive damages.

Therefore, if you are the plaintiff in a civil lawsuit against a debtor in bankruptcy, it is imperative that you immediately cease collection efforts against the debtor, including ensuring the court takes no further action with respect to the case. Debtor’s counsel should file a “Suggestion of Bankruptcy” with the court, which is a notice to the Court that a party to the case is in bankruptcy, and the case may not proceed with respect to them or any claims against them. If the Debtor’s counsel does not file a suggestion of bankruptcy, in order to avoid the penalties of 11 U.S.C. §362(k), you or your attorney should ensure the court is aware that a party to the case has filed for bankruptcy. The Court Clerk or your civil attorney will advise you on the proper way to file such a notice.

Once the case has been stayed (i.e., paused), you must decide if you have grounds to pursue your claims in bankruptcy court, or have a reason why the particular debt is nondischargable by law in bankruptcy. For example, debts which were obtained by false pretenses, or false representations, or actual fraud are not dischargeable, nor are debts owed for fraud or defalcation while acting in a fiduciary capacity, or embezzlement or larceny, among other things. Each of these categories have particular legal requirements in order to prove nondischargability, and in order to prevent the discharge of that debt, you will need to prepare and file an Adversary Proceeding in the Bankruptcy Court.

Procedurally, an Adversary Proceeding is conducted much like a lawsuit in District Court or Superior Court, although the Bankruptcy Court maintains jurisdiction over the resolution of the claims. Removing a case to bankruptcy court can have far-reaching consequences on other aspects of the litigation, and we strongly recommend you consult with an attorney before doing so.

In some situations where your debt is secured or enjoys a legal priority over other debts, and there are assets available in the bankruptcy to pay creditors, it may not be necessary to file an adversarial proceeding, but rather a Proof of Claim. A Proof of Claim is your notice to the court establishing the existence of a debt and the nature of the debt, and will be reviewed by the Trustee and the debtor’s counsel. If funds are available to satisfy your class of debt, you may receive payment (partial or full, depending on the assets obtained from the debtor) from the bankruptcy trustee on behalf of the debtor’s bankruptcy estate.

Regardless, if you are involved in litigation and the opposing party files for bankruptcy, contact Attorney Matthew P. Trask to discuss how the bankruptcy will affect your case and claims moving forward. To fail to assert your rights in the bankruptcy case so could be an extremely costly mistake.

FAQ #16: Who will know about my bankruptcy?

The bankruptcy code requires that you disclose all debts owed, and those creditors will be sent Notice of the bankruptcy filing. Therefore, anyone that you owe money to will learn about your bankruptcy.

Additionally, many bankruptcies are filed to discharge un-liquidated or contingent claims – claims arising from a lawsuit, for example – so the adverse party in the lawsuit will be aware of your filing.

Co-debtors must also be disclosed and will receive notice of filing; as will anyone that holds a leasehold interest with the debtor, such as a landlord or tenant, regardless of whether the rent is up to date.

In addition, bankruptcy is a court case. The existence of a court filing in any court is a matter of public record, so there will be a public record of a bankruptcy filing. However, this does not necessarily mean that the information will be easily obtainable by the general public. For example, in order to view bankruptcy case documents, one must either go to the Federal Courthouse in the district where the case was filed, or have the requisite credentials to obtain a PACER account (on-line access to Federal Court records). Third-party agencies can also determine that a case was filed through various public records search engines. Credit reporting agencies (Equifax, TransUnion and Experian) are able to obtain similar information. This means that anyone authorized to review your credit report will see your bankruptcy, such as prospective employers conducting an authorized background check or loan officers acting on a credit application.

What hurts your Credit Score and should you care?

The Infographic provided below is helpful, at a glance, in understanding the ways that certain negative events can affect your credit score. This information is most useful for those people who already have good scores, because it tells you what to avoid to keep your score high.

But what if your score is already damaged by missed payments and other issues (foreclosure, debt settlement, etc.)? Should you care about your score?

NO

That answer may surprise you, but in our experience people are more concerned with their credit score than with more immediate present issues. Your credit score is important in that it can affect your ability to obtain loans, mortgages, credit cards, and other financing. But if you are already missing payments on your current debt, then this is not the time to worry about future financing. In other words, your credit score isn't as important as the information on your credit report. Fixing the problems on your report will lead to a good score.

So before you can worry about your score in the future, you must first get your house in order. What we tell our potential clients, in our 1-hour consultation, is that they need to set a realistic budget, whether or not they decide to file for bankruptcy. Even when you have significant debt but believe you can work your way out, you will need a realistic budget to make that happen. Until you can manage your current debt, you should not be worried about borrowing more.

Similarly, if you file for bankruptcy, you need to take steps to make sure you don't end up back in a position where you can't pay your debt. As you would expect bankruptcy is one of the worst things that can happen to your credit score. But if you are in a position to go bankrupt, your score has most likely already been significantly affected by your existing debt.

DISCLAIMER: This infographic is provided by freescore.com as an advertisement. We have reproduced it here because it contains useful and interesting information, however we do not endorse or claim any knowledge of freescore.com. We recommend that all of our clients and potential clients obtain their credit report as soon as possible. While you may choose to purchase a credit monitoring service (freescore.com, freecreditreport.com, etc.), you can obtain your credit report, once every 12 months, at annualcreditreport.com without any cost, trial membership or other enrollment. You also have a right to obtain your credit report directly from each of the three credit bureaus by writing to them directly.


[Via: FreeScore.com credit score]

What happens at the end of successful Corporate Chapter 7 Bankruptcy?

When a corporate entity files for Chapter 7 Bankruptcy (liquidation), the business is essentially asking the bankruptcy trustee to manage the liquidation of corporate assets. The trustee will take any assets of value and distribute those assets to the creditors in order of priority.

A corporate entity does not receive a discharge of debts at the the end of the bankruptcy. Any assets which were not distributed by the trustee are abandoned back to the business which must now be dissolved by the owners. The owners may be subject to collection on debts of the company if they personally guaranteed any of those debts or failed to appropriately separate their personal and corporate assets. However, any strictly corporate debts not satisfied in the bankruptcy are owed solely by the corporate entity and any property abandoned back to the business could still be collected pursuant to state collection laws.

Practically speaking, any assets abandoned back to the business are probably so invaluable as to not be worth collecting. Once any remaining corporate debts are paid, the business can be dissolved and any remaining assets distributed to the owners.

What will happen at your Section 341 Creditor's Meeting?

After a bankruptcy petition is filed under Chapter 7 or 13, each "petitioner" must sit through their section 341 meeting of creditors, usually scheduled approximately 30 days after the filing date. Many of our bankruptcy clients feel anxious leading up to their 341 meeting as they are unsure as to what to expect, but if you are prepared there is nothing to worry about.

The majority of 341 meetings only last five to ten minutes. You are required to bring your social security card and driver's license for identification. The trustee will review your identification, swear you in and ask you a few basic questions after reviewing your petition, for example your current living arrangements, whether you own any businesses, and whether you are the beneficiary of any trusts. If anything on your petition sticks out to the trustee, he or she might ask a few follow-up questions. Usually, if there is something that will stick out to the trustee, your attorney will have already asked you the same questions that the trustee will ask.

Generally, creditors do not attend the 341 meeting, although they have the right to be there and may be given the opportunity to ask you some basic questions. If you owe the IRS taxes, they will often attend the creditors meeting and ask questions relating to the petition. Again, your attorney should prepare you for the potential questions that might be asked if a creditor does decide to attend the meeting.

If you would like more information about how to prepare for your creditor's meeting, contact Attorney Matthew Trask or call 508.655.5980 to schedule a one-hour consultation.

What’s With My Credit Score? - Infographic

Reprinted from Free Credit Score – CreditSesame.com

Under What Circumstances Can Creditors Object to the Discharge of a Debt?

A creditor may object to the discharge of amounts owed to them by the debtor under certain circumstances. If a creditor objects to the discharge of any of the debts listed in your petition or schedules, such objection must be raised within 60 days after the first scheduled §341(a) Meeting of Creditors. Alternatively, the trustee must move to dismiss your case within the 60-day period following the §341(a) Meeting of Creditors if he or she finds that the granting of relief would be an abuse of the provisions of Chapter 7.

If you incurred new debt of $500.00 or more for "luxury goods or services" within the 90-day period before your bankruptcy, or if you obtained a cash advance from a credit card or other loan in the amount of $750.00 or more within the 70-day period before your bankruptcy filing, that debt is presumed to be non-dischargeable, absent the debtor's showing to the contrary.

A creditor may object to your request to discharge a debt if the debt was obtained or incurred as a result of fraud, embezzlement or larceny, or any willful or malicious injuries you have caused others. If the Creditor establishes by a preponderance of the evidence that the debt was obtained by any of the above means, the debt will be deemed non-dischargeable.

Creditors may object to the discharge of certain debts if you have concealed or destroyed any property or financial records; made any false statements in connection with incurring a debt or other financial obligation; withheld financial or other material information; failed to explain losses; failed to respond to material questions permitted under the Federal Rules of Bankruptcy Procedure; or if you were granted a discharge with respect to that debtor in a prior bankruptcy case filed within the last 6 years.

Financial Crisis? You are not alone.

Often people who are deep in debt, are more afraid to confront the reality of their situation than anything else. That fear can lead people to do things they never thought they would do: to stop opening their mail, to stop answering the phone for fear of dealing with bill collectors, or even to lie to their family and friends.

It is important to understand that you are not alone. You are not the first person to go through a crisis and there are resources out there to help you.

To read about how even an economic reporter fell into the trap of overusing credit check out this New York Times article: http://tinyurl.com/qukwpb.