Bankruptcy & Litigation Series: #8 Personal Injury & Torts - Plaintiff Bankruptcy

If you are the Plaintiff in a personal injury case and you file bankruptcy, it is generally a good idea to file a suggestion of bankruptcy to alert the court to the bankruptcy filing.  Most courts will temporary delay the hearing of the case, however 11 U.S.C. s. 362 is not designed for this application.  

Ultimately, the suit itself is an asset of the bankruptcy estate.  Like any other asset, it may be exempt depending on the value of the potential claim.  In the event that it is not exempt (and at all times before being abandoned by the trustee), the Trustee steps into the plaintiff's shoes during the administration of the bankruptcy estate.  The Chapter 7 trustee may then offer to settle, or compel the debtor to pursue the suit (although the Trustee will bear the cost of compensating counsel for any post-petition legal fees).  Any proceeds obtained during the suit (less any exempt portions of any receipts) will be turned over to the trustee as property of the bankruptcy estate and distributed to creditors.   Note that there are additional exemptions for personal injury cases in bankruptcy:  

1. $22,975 for personal injury damages, but not any recovery for pain and suffering or pecuniary loss

2. 100% of any award for loss of future earnings needed for support

3. 100% of any recovery for wrongful death of person you were a dependent of needed for support, and

4. 100% of any award of compensation received for being a crime victim.

5. Pain and suffering and pecuniary loss damages may be exempted under the wildcard exemption and/or unused home equity exemptions 11 U.S.C. 522 (d)(5). 

Therefore, if you are a personal injury plaintiff and file for bankruptcy during the pendency of your case or the possibility of bankruptcy is on the horizon at the conclusion of your case, it is important to work with your personal injury attorney to structure the settlement of your case in a way that maximizes the potential exemptions. 

Practice Tips:

1. If you are close to a personal injury settlement, make sure you consult with a bankruptcy attorney first.
2. Try to settle out the PI case before filing. A right to sue is an asset, and can be taken by the trustee if not exempt, and the trustee then decides how to settle the case.
3. Make sure your PI attorney considers how to structure your settlement in a way that protects as much of the judgment as possible: there are limits to the amount of personal injury damages that can be exempted ($21,625.00), but awards for future medical payments, lost earnings, disability payments, wrongful death and crime victims reparations are exempt 100%.

FAQ #27: What happens to my tax refund when I file bankruptcy?

Your tax refund is what the bankruptcy court would consider an “unliquidated asset”, and is treated by the bankruptcy court like other personal property. Any unissued tax refunds would need to be listed on your bankruptcy schedules as assets, and properly exempted if you want to prevent that property from being seized by the Trustee and applied to pay your creditors. If the tax refund is fully exempt or is abandoned by the trustee, you will not be required to turn it over to the bankruptcy Trustee.

FAQ #20: What assets can I keep (house, car, property)?

When filing bankruptcy as a resident of Massachusetts a debtor can choose to use the exemptions allowed under either State or Federal law, but you must choose one or the other. There are many exemptions that are similar under both schemes, such as the exemption of most qualified retirement plans. Click here to view a table of the maximum exemptions as of April 14, 2011 in categories where the state and federal exemptions differ significantly. On April 7, 2011 a new Massachusetts law went into effect significantly increasing the personal property of Massachusetts residents that is protected from seizure by creditors. Please note that these figures are subject to change and you should consult with an attorney to obtain the most current figures and to decide which option you should choose.

In addition certain types of income may also be exempt from the bankruptcy estate. You should consult with an attorney to obtain further information.

FAQ #19: Will I still be able to keep my checking account? If I choose to switch banks will they give me a checking account?

You will be able to keep your checking account, provided the balance in the account is below the maximum exemption limits. If you have a checking account that is associated with an overdraft account, or a credit card issued by the same bank and file bankruptcy, the bank cannot seize money from your checking account to cover the other debts. Banks are private institutions, so they can decide that they no longer want to do business with you. However, this does not mean that they can keep your money.

If your account is ever closed by your institution, you must be given the funds in the account by bank check. Some financial institutions will make inquiries into your credit history when opening a new account, although these inquiries are usually for the purposes of extending lines of credit or an overdraft account. In addition some institutions may review your check-writing through a service like TeleCheck to determine if you are a risk of passing insufficient checks.

FAQ #15: What is the difference between secured and unsecured debt?

Secured debts are those debts in which the borrower pledges some asset (e.g. a car or property) as collateral for the loan. In the event that the borrower defaults, the creditor takes possession of the asset used as collateral and may sell it to regain some or all of the amount originally lent to the borrower. An example of this is repossession of a car or foreclosure of a home. If the sale of the collateral does not raise enough money to pay off the debt, the creditor can often obtain a deficiency judgment against the borrower for the remaining amount.

Unsecured debt refers to any type of debt or general obligation that is not collateralized by a lien on specific assets of the borrower. In other words, in the event that the borrower fails to pay the debt, there is no collateral that the lender may recover to mitigate its financial losses resulting from the debtor’s failure to pay without suing in court.

FAQ #11: Do I have to tell the Bankruptcy Court about cash?

Yes. In order to file for bankruptcy, all assets must be discharged. This includes cash, accounts receivable, promises to pay, the contents of a safe deposit box, etc. Bankruptcy is not a "pick and choose" proceeding. You cannot not disclose some assets and fail to disclose others. Intentionally omitting assets from your bankruptcy case may result in the denial of your bankruptcy discharge, the dismissal of your bankruptcy case, fines, or imprisonment for bankruptcy fraud.

If you don't see your question and would like more information please do not hesitate to call us at 508.655.5980, e-mail us, or attend one of our weekly Free Debt Relief Clinics.

What’s my car worth? Automotive Valuation for Bankruptcy Purposes

The Bankruptcy Court has provided some guidance for valuing a car for the purpose of a Bankruptcy Petition:

“[A]djusting the Kelley Blue Book or N.A.D.A. Guide retail value for a like vehicle by a reasonable amount in light of any additional evidence presented regarding the condition of the vehicle and any other relevant factors” is an appropriate means of reaching retail value. In re Morales, 387 B.R. at 45.

The court agrees that the Kelley Blue Book is an appropriate starting point for a valuation analysis. The values it supplies are based on actual transactions occurring in relevant regional markets. They are admissible under Federal Rule of Evidence 803(17). The Kelley Blue Book is objective, serves the interests of standardization and predictability, and is cost-effective, which benefits the parties.

But the Kelley Blue Book retail values cannot be the final word. Retail value under 11 U.S.C. § 506(a)(2) and the Kelley Blue Book’s suggested retail value have slightly different meanings. Suggested retail value under the Kelley Blue Book “assumes that the vehicle has been fully reconditioned,” and only “represents dealers’ asking prices and... the starting point for negotiation” between a consumer and a dealer. Kelley Blue Book Auto Market Report 4 (May 2010)

By contrast, 11 U.S.C. § 506(a)(2) requires the retail value to mean “the price a retail merchant would charge for property of that kind considering the age and condition of the property.”

The Kelley Blue Book value therefore must be adjusted for two things. First, it must reflect the actual condition of the car if that condition is not optimal. Second, it must reflect the fact that the Kelley Blue Book value is the asking price for a retail sale, not the final price, as it is reasonable to believe that dealers do not sell vehicles frequently at the asking price."
(See In re Penny)

As a practice tip, consult both NADA and Kelley Blue Book private party value as a starting point, and then consider the actual condition to make appropriate adjustments.

4 Facts Your Divorce Attorney Should know about Bankruptcy? Fact #4: Jurisdiction over Your Assets

Many attorneys specialize their practice in order to better serve their clients. While concentrating on a particular practice area can help attorneys focus on making themselves the best in their field, sometimes it causes them to lose sight of the bigger picture. Divorce cases do not occur in a vacuum. When divorcing spouses face financial troubles it is important to consider the possibility of a bankruptcy and how this could affect the different aspects of a divorce.

We have put together this list of four important facts that divorce attorneys should be aware of, to help them better assist their clients who may also be facing a bankruptcy (or have a spouse who may be forced to file for bankruptcy).

Fact #4: Jurisdiction over Your Assets

When a Debtor files for Bankruptcy, they submit their assets to the jurisdiction of the Bankruptcy Court. This means that when a Debtor files for bankruptcy during a divorce case, the assets that would normally be divided in a divorce case are first subject to the jurisdiction of the Bankruptcy Court. While some assets may be joint, the spouse is merely considered another creditor with rights to the joint property that may be subject to the rights of other creditors as well.

A Bankruptcy Judge may allow the Divorce Court to make decisions relating to the division of property, but this is at their discretion, and the Bankruptcy Judge also has the right to make these decisions directly. This power applies even if the divorce has already become final. The bankruptcy laws allow the trustee to take back any items which were transfered up to two years prior to the bankruptcy filing if the transfer was not for fair value (11 U.S.C. § 548(a)(1)) or up to one year prior to the bankruptcy filing if the transfer was to an insider (11 U.S.C. § 547(b)(4)(B)). This means that the Bankruptcy Court can undo a Separation Agreement or Judgment of Divorce in favor of transferring assets from the ex-spouse to other creditors.

Finally, it is important to understand that filing for bankruptcy means that a debtor gives up their rights to decide what happens to their non-exempt assets. The bankruptcy trustee stands in the shoes of the debtor. This means that they can settle a divorce case giving up any rights the debtor may have in their spouse's property. The duty of the trustee is to the creditors not to the debtor.

These are all important consequences of filing for bankruptcy that should be considered when a bankruptcy is filed during or after a divorce case. If you are in a divorce or were recently divorced make sure you discuss this with your bankruptcy attorney. If you are getting divorced and considering bankruptcy, make sure your divorce attorney understands the consequences of filing bankruptcy or consults with a bankruptcy attorney.

Click here to read Fact #3: Jurisdiction over Your Debts.